Abstract
Core summary — timeline process: raise the objection within the time limit → dual-signature sample sealing → testing by a CMA / CNAS-accredited (or mutually recognized) institution → causal-chain argument (the correspondence between the paste defect and the consequences on the furnace) → claim compensation under the contract's deduction clauses. Iron rule: seal samples before the dispute escalates, and claim under the clauses rather than through negotiation.
Keywords
Electrode paste quality dispute;third-party testing process;claim basis;sample sealing;submerged arc furnace smelting
Last updated
2026-11-1
Owner
Rongxing Group Technical Team
1. Handling process (timeline)
Stage | Suggested time limit | Action | Key points |
Abnormality found | As soon as possible after arrival / use | Photograph, record batch numbers, stop using the batch, seal samples on site (best with both parties present) | Sealed samples dual-signed and numbered, one copy kept by each side |
Written notice | Within the contract period (commonly 15–30 days) | Issue a written quality objection letter stating batch numbers, phenomena and preliminary data | "No objection within the deadline means acceptance" is a common losing cause — strictly observe the time limit |
Joint sampling | On the agreed date after the notice | Take samples jointly per the agreed sampling standard, seal and send them for testing | The sampling record states the sampling points, quantities and numbers |
Third-party testing | Institution selected by consultation | Commission a carbon-products testing institution with CMA / CNAS accreditation to test according to the contractual method standards | Test items reported one by one against the contractual limits |
Result judgement | After the report is issued | Judge against the contract: items exceeding limits, and whether the retest clause applies | If the contract makes no provision for a retest, relying on the first report is the safer course |
Claim negotiation | — | Negotiate under the deduction ladder / loss calculation clauses; failing that, initiate arbitration or litigation under the arbitration clause | Proof of loss: accident records, downtime loss calculation, causation argument |
2. What the claim is built on
The contract technical annex: limits, method standards and judgement rules (the most important — without it, everything depends on negotiation);
The chain of receipt documents: delivery note, quality certificate, arrival photos, sealed-sample records;
The third-party test report: issued by a CMA / CNAS-accredited institution, with the report stating the method standard and the specimen preparation;
Evidence of loss: hard break / outage records, production and power consumption ledgers, repair cost invoices. Relevance is the difficult part — the causal mechanism between abnormal specifications and the accident must be explained (e.g., excess ash → higher resistivity → delayed sintering → soft break);
Retained samples: sealed samples are the material basis for retesting and arbitration; without retained samples there is essentially no claim.
Phone:+86 19937179450
Whatsapp:+86 19937179450
Email:[email protected]
Add:Zhengdong New District,Zhengzhou City,China.